Sam Edelman Women's Hazel Pumps, Black, 8.5 Medium US

Sam Edelman Women's Hazel Pumps have an average rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars across 4,143 ratings.

These may not be ideal for those with very narrow feet, or if precise sizing is critical without the ability to return. offering stylish comfort for many, though fit inconsistencies are noted.

While stylish, they are not ideal for extended periods of standing or walking. Reviewers note that while they are comfortable for stilettos, they are not the comfiest walking shoes for longer events, suggesting they are best suited for office wear or dinners.

Sizing can be inconsistent, with some finding them too small or too large. While the listing states they fit true to size, customer feedback reports inconsistent sizing, with some receiving shoes that are too small or too large, and others finding them to run small and needing to size up.

The heel height is 3.75 inches. The listing specifies a heel height of 3.75 inches, described as a tall, stiletto heel.

They are suitable for an office day but may not be comfortable for all-day standing and walking. While praised for style and comfort in stilettos, one reviewer noted they are not the comfiest walking shoes for longer events, though suitable for a workday at the office or a date night dinner.

The Sam Edelman Women's Hazel Pumps are a popular choice, boasting a 4.4 out of 5-star average rating from over 4,000 reviews. Shoppers frequently praise their stylish design, noting the classic pointed-toe silhouette and leg-lengthening effect. The listing highlights a modern update to the timeless silhouette, featuring a tall, stiletto heel and low-cut vamp for an instant leg-lengthening effect. The use of high-quality leather and features like a padded sock contribute to a comfortable experience for many, with some reviewers stating they feel like a glove after a few wears. The brand also incorporates new fit technology with a padded sock for added comfort without sacrificing style. They are described as versatile, suitable for office wear, parties, and nights out, making them a wardrobe must-have for various occasions.

However, the most significant concern raised by buyers is inconsistent sizing and fit. Customers report receiving shoes that are either too small or too large, even when ordering their usual size. This inconsistency means that while the listing states the shoes fit true to size, actual experiences vary, with one reviewer stating they needed to size up by a half-size. Another community report highlights that the standard fit can be too wide, and a narrow option is no longer available, having been discontinued years ago. This presents a notable challenge for potential buyers seeking a precise fit, despite the listing's positive fit-to-size sentiment.

Despite the fit issues, many still find the shoes comfortable for their intended use. Reviewers often mention that for high heels, these offer a good level of comfort, especially with the cushioned insoles. The listing also specifies a moderate cushioning level and special features like cushioning. However, they are not typically recommended for very long periods of standing or extensive walking, with one user noting they are not the comfiest walking shoes for longer events, though suitable for an office day or dinner. The heel height of 3.75 inches is considered stylish but can contribute to discomfort during prolonged wear, especially given the stiletto heel type.

The material quality and style are consistently praised, suggesting that when the fit is right, these pumps are a valued addition to a wardrobe. The brand's reputation for quality leather and design is evident, with the outer material being 100% leather and the sole made of synthetic material. The pointed toe style further enhances their classic appeal. The presence of a padded sock and cushioning aims to mitigate discomfort, but the primary drawback remains the unpredictable sizing, making it a risk for some buyers. Overall, the Sam Edelman Hazel Pumps are a stylish and generally comfortable option for specific occasions, provided buyers are prepared to navigate potential sizing discrepancies.

Customers report inconsistent sizing, with some receiving shoes that are too small or too large when ordering their usual size.

Analysis of the product listing's features, description, and specifications, cross-referenced with buyer reviews and community forum discussions for this specific product. Marketplace rating and review count were also considered.

Everything on this page traces back to the listing published for this product on Amazon.com. At the analysis date that listing showed 4.4 stars across 4,143 reviews. The write-up works from 8 verified data points, drawn from buyer reviews for this product. Analysis generated on 2026-10-31.